Skip to content
cccskills
FreePublished on GitHub

ieee-reviewer

Review IEEE conference, journal, Transactions, Letters, or magazine manuscripts from a technical reviewer perspective using routed IEEE review gates. Use when evaluating scope fit, novelty, validity, data, clarity, compliance, advancement, engineering significance, method soundness, experiment sufficiency, baseline fairness, figure/table quality, formatting risks, rejection risk, major revision strategy, pre-submission readiness, or the quality and specificity of reviewer comments that may be generic, careless, contradictory, or possibly AI-generated.

The English summary is being prepared. Showing the original description.

CloudWave818/ieee-skills

Run score Not tested

See how to install

Files included (38)

  • SKILL.md2.7 KB
  • agents/openai.yaml207 B
  • manifest.yaml3.4 KB
  • static/core/output-format.md318 B
  • static/core/stance.md471 B
  • static/core/workflow.md461 B
  • static/fragments/domain/ai-ml.md169 B
  • static/fragments/domain/circuits.md137 B
  • static/fragments/domain/communications.md158 B
  • static/fragments/domain/control.md155 B
  • static/fragments/domain/embedded-systems.md152 B
  • static/fragments/domain/general-engineering.md156 B
  • static/fragments/domain/power-energy.md169 B
  • static/fragments/domain/robotics.md129 B
  • static/fragments/domain/signal-processing.md149 B
  • static/fragments/review_scope/abstract-intro.md283 B
  • static/fragments/review_scope/experiments.md201 B
  • static/fragments/review_scope/figures-tables.md349 B
  • static/fragments/review_scope/full-manuscript.md221 B
  • static/fragments/review_scope/method.md260 B
  • static/fragments/review_scope/rebuttal-readiness.md309 B
  • static/fragments/review_scope/review-comment-audit.md1.3 KB
  • static/fragments/strictness/harsh.md194 B
  • static/fragments/strictness/quick.md84 B
  • static/fragments/strictness/standard.md128 B
  • static/fragments/venue/conference.md211 B
  • static/fragments/venue/generic.md111 B
  • static/fragments/venue/journal.md144 B
  • static/fragments/venue/letter.md167 B
  • static/fragments/venue/magazine.md138 B
  • static/fragments/venue/transaction.md181 B
  • static/gates/advancement.md337 B
  • static/gates/clarity.md383 B
  • static/gates/compliance.md447 B
  • static/gates/data.md382 B
  • static/gates/novelty.md278 B
  • static/gates/scope.md316 B
  • static/gates/validity.md309 B

SKILL.md (original)

Review the instructions the agent will receive before you install.

IEEE Reviewer Router

Use this skill to simulate a strict IEEE-style technical review. The goal is to find rejection risks and actionable fixes, not to flatter the manuscript.

Do not invent reviewer identities or editorial decisions. Review only the supplied manuscript facts and clearly mark missing materials.

Routing Protocol

  1. Read manifest.yaml.
  2. Read every file listed under always_load.
  3. Detect the axes:
    • venue_type: transaction / journal / letter / conference / magazine / generic.
    • review_scope: full-manuscript / abstract-intro / method / experiments / figures-tables / rebuttal-readiness / review-comment-audit.
    • domain: ai-ml / communications / control / signal-processing / power-energy / circuits / robotics / embedded-systems / general-engineering.
    • strictness: quick / standard / harsh.
  4. State the detected axes in one short line.
  5. Load only the matching fragments and gates.
  6. Review using IEEE gates in this order:
    • scope,
    • novelty,
    • validity,
    • data,
    • clarity,
    • compliance,
    • advancement.
  7. Add first-impression checks for figures, tables, formatting, notation, and language.
  8. For review-comment audits, judge observable quality problems rather than accusing a reviewer of using AI.
  9. Return findings ordered by severity.

Output Contract

Default output:

Review setup
- Detected axes:
- Assessment boundary:
- Central claim:
- Visible evidence:

Major rejection risks
- [severity] issue -> why it matters -> fix

Technical review
- Scope:
- Novelty:
- Validity:
- Data and experiments:
- Clarity:
- Compliance:
- Advancement:

Presentation and first impression
- Figures/tables:
- Formatting/notation:
- Writing:

Actionable revision plan
1. ...

Likely decision posture
- [bounded, non-editorial assessment]

Use Critical, Major, and Minor severity labels.

Red Lines

Do not claim the editor's final decision.

Do not invent experiments, results, citations, line numbers, figure contents, or reviewer biographies.

Do not turn the review into author rebuttal unless the user asks for ieee-response.

Reviews

No reviews yet. Tell others what you thought.

Comments

No login needed. Share how it worked for you, ask a question, or note where it did not run.

No comments yet. Be the first to write one.

Comments are published right away. Do not include personal information such as email addresses or phone numbers. Up to 2 URLs.

0 / 1,000 characters

This form is protected by reCAPTCHA, and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

More skills from this repository

ieee-citation

Free

Check, clean, verify, and improve IEEE citations, references, BibTeX entries, citation positioning, related-work logic, DOI metadata, venue names, and reference formatting using routed citation and metadata guidance. Use when preparing IEEE manuscripts, fixing bibliography errors, verifying reference completeness, improving related work, checking whether citations support claims, or identifying missing classic/recent baselines.

The English summary is being prepared. Showing the original description.

CloudWave818/ieee-skills405Updated Aug 12, 2026

ieee-experiment

Free

Design, audit, and strengthen experimental validation for IEEE manuscripts using routed claim-evidence checks. Use when planning experiments, selecting baselines, designing ablations, choosing metrics, checking fairness, adding robustness tests, explaining results, analyzing complexity, building claim-to-evidence matrices, or responding to reviewer concerns about insufficient experiments.

The English summary is being prepared. Showing the original description.

CloudWave818/ieee-skills405Updated Aug 12, 2026

ieee-figure-table

Free

Audit, redesign, generate, and improve IEEE manuscript figures, tables, captions, result presentation, plotting scripts, visual polish, hybrid Python/R plus vector-editor workflows, publication-ready matplotlib house style, and layout using routed visual-evidence checks. Use when checking or creating plot readability, axes, legends, line overlap, table structure, metric reporting, captions, grayscale accessibility, IEEE one-column/two-column layout, figure/table placement, claim-evidence mapping, reviewer first-impression risks, matplotlib/seaborn or ggplot2 figure code, SVG/PDF/TIFF/PNG export, Illustrator/Inkscape/PowerPoint/Figma finishing plans, or IEEE-style engineering evidence graphics.

The English summary is being prepared. Showing the original description.

CloudWave818/ieee-skills405Updated Aug 12, 2026

ieee-latex

Free

Diagnose, fix, and improve IEEEtran LaTeX manuscripts using routed template, layout, float, equation, algorithm, table, bibliography, and PDF-compliance guidance. Use when fixing IEEE LaTeX compile errors, overfull boxes, float placement, two-column layout, figure sizing, tables, equations, algorithms, BibTeX, citation commands, template compliance, or final submission PDF checks.

The English summary is being prepared. Showing the original description.

CloudWave818/ieee-skills405Updated Aug 12, 2026

ieee-paper-reader

Free

Read, decompose, and analyze IEEE-style papers using routed technical-reading workflows. Use when extracting problem setting, object-method-condition logic, contributions, method pipeline, equations, datasets, baselines, metrics, ablations, limitations, replication details, citation role, related-work positioning, implementation notes, or reviewer-style assessment from a paper, PDF, abstract, or manuscript excerpt.

The English summary is being prepared. Showing the original description.

CloudWave818/ieee-skills405Updated Aug 12, 2026

ieee-polishing

Free

Polish, translate, diagnose, and restructure technical manuscript text into IEEE-style academic English using routed failure-mode guidance. Use for IEEE abstracts, introductions, related work, methods, experiments, conclusions, figure captions, rebuttals, Chinese-to-English technical writing, AI-like or template-like academic prose, and engineering prose that needs clearer problem logic, contribution framing, method rationale, evidence discipline, natural author voice, or reviewer-ready wording.

The English summary is being prepared. Showing the original description.

CloudWave818/ieee-skills405Updated Aug 12, 2026

See all skills by CloudWave818

Report a problem with this skill