/issue-resolver N

Issue → atomic PR in 6 steps.

Invocation

Invocation (N = issue number)	What happens
/issue-resolver <N>	Interactive; user picks the plan
/issue-resolver <N> --auto	No prompts; set by /auto-pilot
/issue-resolver <N> --no-run-log	Modifier, orthogonal to --auto: append nothing to .idd/runs.jsonl, return telemetry (Run-log entry)

Prerequisites

Run these checks in order before any operation. A non-zero exit or empty output stops the run: print that check's references/error-messages.md error and the Closing Summary BLOCKED block.

1. Git repository: git rev-parse --git-dir.
2. gh installed: which gh.
3. gh authenticated: gh auth status.
4. Remote present: git remote -v prints at least one line.

Repo Sync Before Edits (mandatory)

In-place path only; worktree paths start from the fetched base, and an invalid IDD_CALLER_WORKTREE=1 is a stop, never a sync bypass. Use the stash-first pattern: copy the snippet and recovery from references/docs/sync-conventions.md (Quick Reference (Copy-Paste Snippet)), never a bare rebase on a dirty tree. A missing origin or a conflict stops and asks (interactive), or aborts (auto).

Configuration

Load config once; never re-read it. Run python3 references/scripts/gi-config.py — Working directory: the repo root; Script path: absolute, as the Bundled dependency precheck resolves its list. It prints {"config": …, "config_file": …, "first_run": …} merged over the defaults below (rationale: references/steps/step-0-preflight.md, Configuration load).

• Exit 0 — use config.
• Exit 3 — invalid .idd.yml: print the references/error-messages.md error (Invalid config), stop.
• Script file absent — a broken install and not a degrade: stop, print ✗ Missing bundled dependency.
• Anything else (no python3, non-zero exit, unparsable stdout) — print ⚠ gi-config unavailable — reading .idd.yml by hand and read it yourself instead of the script (else legacy .gitissue.yml, printing ⚠ legacy .gitissue.yml found — rename to .idd.yml), over the keys and defaults below.

Either path: no .idd.yml (first_run) prints ○ First run — using default config. Run /init-idd to customize.

Capture the run clock here: chain that same python3 invocation as python3 …; ec=$?; date +%s >&2; exit "$ec"; the stderr epoch is run_started_epoch, the Run Stats Footer's elapsed anchor. Take date +%s again as each [N/5] step starts and at the terminal outcome: those boundaries are the run log's phases (references/report-templates.md).

Defaults and behavior per key: references/docs/config-schema.md — issue.auto_normalize · resolve.approval_gate · resolve.branch_prefix · resolve.auto_test · resolve.test_timeout · resolve.max_commits · resolve.qa_max_cycles · resolve.adaptive_effort · resolve.ui_review.browser_review · resolve.borrow_skills: false.

---

Subagent Architecture

Heavy work goes to subagents (shared/agents/), keeping the main agent's context window lean: it owns Step 0, Step 4's loop and Step 5; Steps 1-3 each spawn one (Subagent Architecture Diagram). Prompts: references/agents/<name>.md; conventions: references/docs/shared-agent-conventions.md. Without the Agent tool (e.g. Claude.ai), run each step inline via its fallback instructions.

Spawning a subagent (canonical pattern)

Role, description and prompt file change per step. Do NOT set subagent_type:

Agent(
  description="{role} — {action} issue #N",
  prompt=<{agent-file}.md prompt with {variables} replaced>,
  # never subagent_type — the default general-purpose agent, not "code-reviewer"
)

Per-role overrides: at every spawn apply references/docs/agent-overrides.md — the resolved agents.model.<role> / agents.effort.<role> for the spawned role (codebase-researcher, synthesizer, implementer, code-reviewer, ui-reviewer, fixer); null (the default) passes nothing.

Orchestrating the agents

Name the role in description, size model/effort per references/docs/agent-model-effort.md, and read each return before advancing: a missing or blocking return stops (interactive) or takes the auto behavior (Orchestrating the agents).

Bundled dependency precheck

Check every path below exists relative to this SKILL.md's directory. A missing path stops the run: print the ✗ Missing bundled dependency block from references/error-messages.md (Bundled dependencies); never guess a prompt.

references/agents/codebase-researcher.md
references/agents/synthesizer.md
references/agents/implementer.md
references/agents/code-reviewer.md
references/agents/ui-reviewer.md
references/agents/fixer.md
references/pipeline-steps.md
references/steps/step-0-preflight.md
references/steps/step-0h-analysis-reuse.md
references/steps/step-0i-caller-payload.md
references/steps/step-1-research.md
references/steps/step-2-plan.md
references/steps/step-3-implement.md
references/steps/step-4-qa.md
references/steps/step-5-deliver.md
references/report-templates.md
references/run-stats.md
references/bug-verification.md
references/skill-index.md
references/error-messages.md
references/docs/sync-conventions.md
references/docs/naming-conventions.md
references/docs/pre-commit-security.md
references/docs/idd-methodology.md
references/docs/github-projects-sync.md
references/docs/run-log-schema.md
references/docs/config-schema.md
references/docs/agent-model-effort.md
references/docs/agent-overrides.md
references/docs/shared-agent-conventions.md
references/docs/platform-github.md
references/docs/terminal-style.md
references/docs/ui-review.md
references/scripts/gi-config.py
references/scripts/gi-runlog.py
references/scripts/gi-secscan.py
references/scripts/gi-branch.py
references/scripts/gi-gh.py
references/scripts/gi-issue.py
references/scripts/gi-state.py
references/scripts/gi-receipt.py
references/scripts/gi-sensitive.py
references/scripts/gi-premise.py
references/scripts/gi-sketch.py
references/scripts/gi-recipe.py

---

Pipeline Overview

6 steps (0-5) — Preflight, Research, Plan, Implement, QA, Deliver — each printing a [N/5] line (● → ✓/✗); expected output example: references/report-templates.md (Expected Inline Pipeline Output).

Step completion reports

Each step closes with √/× per check and a Result: PASS | PARTIAL | FAIL line (Step Completion Reports in references/report-templates.md, read it now). A step is incomplete until Result: prints.

---

Step 0 — Preflight

Open with ● Preflight check for issue #N....

0a — Fetch issue

GitHub reads share the boundary in references/scripts/gi-gh.py. Classify any framed caller payload first (/auto-pilot captured it in mode-neutral Step 1.2b); Step 0i — Caller payload gate in references/steps/step-0i-caller-payload.md is its single home — issue_payload = supplied | partial | absent, the mandatory live gh issue view N --json state,comments,updatedAt under supplied, the exact match between retained and live updatedAt before 0d, discard-and-refresh on mismatch (identical for individual, array, and keyed-map payloads), never a gate. Then run python3 references/scripts/gi-issue.py {N} --fields number,title,body,labels,assignees,state,comments,updatedAt, reading .issue unless the gate substitutes a payload. Capture updatedAt here — 0d's gh issue edit bumps it, so 0h uses this pre-normalization value. Exit 3 stops; anything else degrades to gh issue view {N} --json number,title,body,labels,assignees,state,comments,updatedAt. 0d rewrites the body, so it MUST end with python3 references/scripts/gi-issue.py {N} --invalidate. <!-- a:rs-0a-payload-concurrency -->

Not found: error, stop. Closed: warning, stop.

0b — Check for existing work

1. List branches: git branch -a | grep -i "{N}".
2. List open PRs: gh pr list --state open --json number,title,body,headRefName --limit 20. A PR targets the issue when its body has Closes #N, Fixes #N or Resolves #N.
3. If an open PR targets it: print the ⚠ PR already targets issue block from references/error-messages.md (Guards), stop, return status: pr_in_progress with its pr_number and branch_name, and never close the issue (Early exit).

Only a merged PR or a closing commit on the default branch is already_resolved.

0c — Guards

Interactive: warn and ask if assigned elsewhere, or on wontfix/blocked/do-not-merge labels. Auto: skip the assignment guard, log blocking labels, never stop.

0d — Auto-normalize

If issue.auto_normalize is true and the body lacks a <!-- idd:normalized v1 --> marker (a legacy gitissue:normalized one counts):

1. Security label check (SPEC §1.4) — before any rewrite scan labels for security, CVE, vulnerability (case-insensitive). On a match:

   • Auto mode (--auto / IDD_AUTO_MODE=1): print the ⚠ … Skipping auto-normalization warning (references/error-messages.md → Security-labeled issue (skip)), first matching label as {label}, continue without rewriting.
   • Interactive mode: same warning, then ask for explicit operator confirmation; default no, a decline continuing without normalization.

2. Normalize inline — otherwise, structure-only as /issue-creator Normalize mode (the resolver does not invoke /issue-creator as a subprocess):

   1. Classify the type and generate the body with the marker.
   2. Back up the original body in a comment.
   3. Run gh issue edit, then python3 references/scripts/gi-issue.py {N} --invalidate, then re-fetch.
   4. On any failure, warn and continue with the original body (references/error-messages.md → Auto-normalization failed).

0e — Workspace (interactive only)

Derive one {branch_name} first: python3 references/scripts/gi-branch.py {N} --from-issue --type {type}, reading .branch. --from-issue is mandatory — never put the issue title or configured prefix on the command line (references/steps/step-0-preflight.md → Step 0e — Workspace). {type} is one of six classified literals. Exit 3 stops; anything else degrades to references/docs/naming-conventions.md.

Auto mode (--auto / IDD_AUTO_MODE=1): skip this offer entirely. A set IDD_CALLER_WORKTREE=1 uses the validated caller-managed path; otherwise go to 0f.

Interactive mode: offer a git worktree, so work never touches the user's tree:

◆ Workspace for issue #N
┄┄┄┄┄┄┄┄┄┄┄┄┄┄┄┄┄┄┄┄┄┄

    Branch:    {branch_name}
    Worktree:  ../{repo}-worktrees/{branch_name with / → -}
    Setup:     copies your gitignored local config (.env*, and similar),
               then runs this project's detected install/bootstrap.

  Accepting keeps your current working tree untouched. Declining uses the current working tree with the existing sync and branch behavior.

  Resolve in a new worktree? [Y/n]

Accept replaces 0f — Create branch and the mandatory Repo Sync; decline runs mandatory Repo Sync then 0f. Creation, setup, cleanup: Step 0e — Workspace.

0f — Create branch

The in-place path; worktree paths already checked out the branch. Reuse the derived {branch_name} (0e — Workspace, references/docs/naming-conventions.md). If it exists: interactive asks continue or fresh, auto takes continue.

0g — Complexity gate (select the pipeline profile)

Decide before Step 1 how much pipeline this issue earns; the XS … XL scale and safety rules: references/docs/agent-model-effort.md (Complexity → pipeline profile). resolve.adaptive_effort: false pins full; else read the pre-work Effort band in ## Metadata, never later agent output:

• XS/S asserted (not (needs review)) → light; M/L/XL → full
• XS/S low-confidence, or absent/unparseable → full (ambiguous → fuller)

What light collapses — the single home for this rule. Mechanics: the light profile subsection of references/steps/step-1-research.md and references/steps/step-2-plan.md.

Step	light behavior
1 — Research	Lighter pass; the already-resolved check still runs.
2 — Plan	Do not spawn the synthesizer; derive a minimal plan inline, no design-confirm checkpoint; the sensitive-change gate still runs. Unless 0h set analysis_reuse = fresh: Step 2 — Plan → reuse governs, options are lifted, and the design-confirm checkpoint does apply.
3 — Propose relevant skills	Skip propose/install; selected_skills = []. Leftover teardown still runs (Step 3), except in a parallel lane (IDD_CALLER_WORKTREE=1).
4 — QA	Cap the loop at 1 cycle; one reviewer spawn still runs.
5 — Deliver	Unchanged.

Revise upward only. {workspace_note} is (worktree) in a worktree, else empty; effort: full prints even under resolve.adaptive_effort: false:

[0/5] Preflight    ✓ issue #N open, branch: {branch_name}{workspace_note}, effort: {profile}

0h — Analysis reuse gate <!-- a:rs-0h-skill -->

Set analysis_reuse to fresh, stale or absent by the five-condition predicate in references/steps/step-0h-analysis-reuse.md (Step 0h — Analysis reuse gate) — its single home. fresh seeds Step 1 and skips Step 2's synthesizer; stale/absent run the full pipeline. Any doubt is stale (fail-safe). Skipped when resolve.adaptive_effort: false.

---

Step 1 — Research

Understand the issue, the affected code and candidate solutions; the same pass verifies it is not already fixed (auto then closes it). Spawn the researcher (references/agents/codebase-researcher.md). Payload, phases, early exit, fallback: Step 1 — Research.

Profiles. light — see the profile table in Step 0g; a high/complex signal revises upward to full. analysis_reuse = fresh (0h) — pass prior_analysis for the seeded verify-first pass: confirm or refute, never trust; the already-resolved check still runs. triage_context has no commit pin, so it may only reorder a scan (→ reuse, → triage_context).

---

Step 2 — Plan

Generate options and select one. Spawn the synthesizer (references/agents/synthesizer.md); it returns minimal / balanced / comprehensive options and recommends one (Step 2 — Plan). Design sketches: when the change adds or reshapes a domain type, state or transition and the repo has a static checker, options differ in structure instead, each carrying caller code the repo's checker type-checks, never runs; references/scripts/gi-sketch.py rejects designs that accept an invalid transition and may switch the selection (Step 2 — Plan → Design sketches).

Profiles. light — see the profile table in Step 0g. analysis_reuse = fresh (0h) skips the same spawn but wins Step 2 when both apply — a replacement, not an addition: lift options[], recommended_option, overall_complexity, overall_risk from the analysis, each rejection_reason from decision_record.options_rejected[] (→ reuse).

Sensitive-change gate (every profile, every mode)

Size never exempts a change. Once an option is selected, references/scripts/gi-sensitive.py --classify checks the labels and planned paths; when sensitive, run falsifiable load-bearing probes, a fresh code-reviewer challenge, and adjudication where one unrebutted blocker at any confidence holds the plan. --adjudicate decides; stop is a safety stop in auto mode (Step 2 — Plan → Sensitive-change gate).

Design-confirm checkpoint (high-complexity, interactive only)

Exactly one extra agreement point before code is written, when both hold: overall_complexity: L/XL or overall_risk: High, and interactive mode (--auto/IDD_AUTO_MODE=1 never pauses). Accept (default) → Step 3; decline → stop, recorded in the PR Decision Record (Step 2 — Plan → Design-confirm checkpoint).

---

Step 3 — Implement

Propose relevant skills

Optionally augment the implementer with external skills from references/skill-index.md: detect, propose, accept into selected_skills; internal agents remain the fallback. Borrow/install, {name, origin} records via references/scripts/gi-state.py, teardown of origin: borrowed only, auto-mode: references/steps/step-3-implement.md (Step 3 — Propose relevant skills).

Then spawn the implementer (references/agents/implementer.md) with the plan, branch name, naming conventions and selected_skills. Bug issues first run the red-capable reproduction checkpoint — reproduce, confirm red, fix, convert to a regression test — surfaced in the Decision Record and acceptance table; others skip it, auto never blocks (references/bug-verification.md). Payload, guardrails, fallback: Step 3; light: profile table in Step 0g.

---

Step 4 — QA

Loop: review → test → fix until clean or the cycle cap — light=1 (profile table in Step 0g); full+low/medium=2; full+high=resolve.qa_max_cycles. Record ceiling/breach_reason. Premise reset: two failed fixes sharing a premise block the next fix — cap and interactive continue included — until rerunnable diagnostics support a revised premise; references/scripts/gi-premise.py decides (Step 4 — QA → Premise reset).

Spawning the code reviewer

Spawn a fresh reviewer (references/agents/code-reviewer.md) each cycle. On blocking issues, spawn or re-message the fixer (references/agents/fixer.md) with issue context, branch/base branch, findings, failing output, the commit message fix({scope}): address review feedback (#N), and the pre-commit security gate it MUST run before committing — security_convention (references/docs/pre-commit-security.md), secscan_script (references/scripts/gi-secscan.py), secscan_policy_ref (origin/${base}) as spawn variables; paths and a ref only. Read the fixer's JSON result and decide on another cycle — never fix inline when the Agent tool exists.

UI/UX review (auto-detected)

UI review is auto-detected per issue (no config flag): scan the issue body and diff for UI work before cycling. The code UI review always runs; the browser UI review runs only when a running app is reachable and opted in, else skips with a warning. Detection, the ui-reviewer spawn and the ui_review.browser_review gate: references/docs/ui-review.md; mechanics: Step 4 — UI/UX review.

Verification recipe: when the base branch commits .idd-recipe.json (or legacy .gitissue-recipe.json), each cycle also runs it through references/scripts/gi-recipe.py: launch, drive the capabilities the diff maps, keep evidence, tear down the owned instance. Auto mode runs it only when the recipe opts in resolve (Step 4 — QA → Verification recipe).

---

Step 5 — Deliver

Verify all tests pass

With resolve.auto_test true (default), run the full suite once more after QA; false skips. Under auto_test, not over it: when tests_state's SHA equals git rev-parse HEAD and git status --porcelain=v1 --untracked-files=all is empty, a clean QA cycle already ran this suite on this tree — skip it, print ○ Test suite: skipped (last green {count}@{sha_short} == HEAD). Nothing recorded, or any doubt, runs it (Step 4 — QA → Last-green test state, the variable's single home). <!-- a:rs-deliver-clean-tree -->

A failure prints ✗ Final test run failed — PR not created and stops, even in auto.

Update documentation

1. List the user-visible names the diff changes (commands, flags, config keys, public functions, output strings).
2. Search README*, docs/, CHANGELOG* and the changed files' docstrings for each name.
3. Update each match describing the old behavior; add a CHANGELOG entry if that file exists.
4. No match: record docs: none found in the Evidence row.

Push branch and create PR

Run the branch-diff scan first: export IDD_AUTO_MODE=1 in auto mode, then from the repo root run python3 references/scripts/gi-secscan.py --range "origin/${base}" --policy-ref "origin/${base}". It reads security.* from .idd.yml (else legacy .gitissue.yml) at the base ref: never pass a config value on the command line, never let the scanned branch supply its policy (Pre-push secret scan).

• Pass needs all four: exit 0, policy_source equal to the requested ref:origin/…, verdict not block, scanned not 0 while skipped is above 0.
• Exit 1 is the block verdict — stop, do not push, report blocking[]. Exit 3 (uncompilable security.*) also stops.
• No python3, exit 2, exit 4 — degrade: print ⚠ gi-secscan unavailable — running the documented scan and run the Primary Pattern in references/docs/pre-commit-security.md over git diff --name-only "origin/${base}"...HEAD. Exit 1 without JSON is a crash — treat as exit 2.

Never read a non-zero exit as a pass. Only after it passes:

# gated by the gi-secscan.py pass above — see references/docs/pre-commit-security.md
git push -u origin {branch_name}
gh pr create --title "{pr_title}" --body "{pr_body}"

PR title: {type}({scope}): {description} (#{issue_number}) (references/docs/naming-conventions.md)

PR body: fill PR Body Template in references/report-templates.md; never omit its Decision Record, Test Results or Acceptance Criteria Verification (references/docs/idd-methodology.md). Its last line is the QA handoff marker: fill it only when QA exited clean, else drop it — never append a second copy (QA handoff marker owns the per-field omit rules). head= is git rev-parse HEAD after the last commit.

Copy that line out of the template character-for-character and substitute only the {braced} tokens; never re-word or recall a field name:

<!-- idd:qa v1 head={head_sha} profile={profile} cycles={qa_cycles} review=clean tests={test_count}@{tests_sha} ui={ui_legs}:{ui_result}@{ui_sha} -->

review=clean has no synonym: verdict=, status= or result= make the marker stale (QA handoff marker explains why).

Revision receipt <!-- a:rs-revision-receipt -->

The marker alone is not evidence, because whoever opened the PR can write it. Whenever the marker is filled, record its receipt while HEAD is still the marker's head= and git status --porcelain=v1 --untracked-files=all is empty. Without a receipt, /issue-pr-review reads the marker as stale. The JSON record carries profile, cycles, review: "clean", ui (the marker's ui= value), and tests: the tests= count and SHA plus the command that ran, or null when the marker omits tests=, plus artifacts: the recipe_state evidence paths when a recipe ran (Revision receipt in references/report-templates.md). The script prints the sha it recorded, which must equal the marker's head=.

printf '%s' "$receipt_json" | python3 references/scripts/gi-receipt.py --write

• Exit 0: written.
• Exit 3: invalid record, nothing written. Fix it and retry once, or ship without a receipt.
• Exit 4, or no python3: print ⚠ No revision receipt — the reviewer will run its full pipeline. Ship without a receipt and never hand-write one, because the script's clean-tree and HEAD checks are what a receipt attests.

Project board sync

With projects.sync_enabled true, set status_map.done (references/docs/github-projects-sync.md), then print [5/5] Deliver.

Run-log entry (monitoring)

At every terminal outcome — success, already_resolved, failed — append exactly one JSON line to .idd/runs.jsonl, unless invoked with --no-run-log, which appends nothing and returns telemetry. That is the single writer rule under /auto-pilot, independent of --auto: a standalone /issue-resolver <N> --auto still writes. Derivation: references/report-templates.md (Run-log entry — field derivation and suppression), per references/docs/run-log-schema.md.

# Exactly one runs. --echo validates the telemetry you return and writes nothing.
if [ -n "$no_run_log" ]; then printf '%s' "$run_json" | python3 references/scripts/gi-runlog.py --echo; else printf '%s' "$run_json" | python3 references/scripts/gi-runlog.py --append; fi
# Fallback when `python3` is unavailable or the script exits 4: mkdir -p .idd && printf '%s\n' "$run_json" >> .idd/runs.jsonl

Exit 3: the record is invalid and nothing was written — a stop, not a degrade: never append $run_json raw. Correct the record and re-run, or drop the line. Every other write failure is non-fatal — use the fallback append, never block the result. Only append; never rewrite or reorder lines.

---

Closing Summary

Emit one closing block at every terminal outcome, stops included. Read the Review contract in references/report-templates.md (Closing Summary), then print its matching variant: Result: first (DONE, PARTIAL or BLOCKED), then Evidence:, Uncertainty:, Decision: and Next action:. Then the run-stats footer (references/run-stats.md) prints last, with tokens only where the host reported a count.

---

Auto-Pilot Mode

With --auto (or under /auto-pilot) no step prompts. Invariants:

• Environment: export IDD_AUTO_MODE=1 before any shell snippet consulting it (references/docs/pre-commit-security.md).
• Workspace: in-place is the default resolution path. Skip Step 0e and allow no git worktree add on the default resolution path; run mandatory Repo Sync, then 0f. With max_parallel > 1 a resolver may receive IDD_CALLER_WORKTREE=1 and use that workspace, never creating or cleaning it up.
• Never blocks: every decision point has an auto behavior (Auto-mode behavior by step); every terminal outcome runs borrow teardown. No [y/N], Choose: or Continue? prompts.
• Deliver: create the PR; never merge (/auto-pilot's or /issue-pr-review's job). Under /auto-pilot the profile is returned in telemetry; a standalone --auto run writes it.

Edge Cases

No ACs, empty body, 20+ files, test failure or timeout, existing branch: Edge Cases.

Platform Driver and Output Conventions

Tracker access uses the GitHub driver: --json with explicit fields, never parsed text (references/docs/platform-github.md). Output follows references/docs/terminal-style.md (symbols, indent, URLs on their own line, ≤80 chars, no animation). Errors use references/error-messages.md's format.