Skip to content
cccskills
FreePublished on GitHub

costly-signaling

Why expensive, wasteful, effortful, or self-deprecating actions build trust and desire — Rory Sutherland on signalling. Use when the problem is credibility or desirability rather than meaning: the user asks 'why don't people trust us', 'how do we look more credible/committed/premium', 'is our guarantee/warranty worth it', 'should we spend on brand advertising', 'how do we justify a higher price', or wonders why a cheaper-looking competitor wins. Covers costly signals (advertising spend, guarantees, over-delivery), price-as-quality-signal (Veblen goods), and the Pratfall Effect (admitting a real flaw to gain trust). Inspired by Rory Sutherland's *Alchemy*. Routed to from psycho-logic. 日本語の相談(「信頼されない」「安心してもらえない」「強気な価格で売りたい」「広告費に意味はある?」)にも使う。

中文咨询(“不被信任”“想以高价出售”“广告费有意义吗?”)也适用。

The English summary is being prepared. Showing the original description.

Run score Not tested

See how to install

Files included (2)

  • SKILL.md6.3 KB
  • evals/evals.json17.2 KB

SKILL.md (original)

Review the instructions the agent will receive before you install.

Costly Signaling — trust is bought with waste

People can't see your intentions, only your actions — so they read your costly, hard-to-fake actions as proof. Anything cheap and easy to fake (a slogan, a claim, a promise) carries little signal. Anything expensive, effortful, or risky to you carries a lot. This is why "wasteful" things work.

The principle

A signal is credible in proportion to how much it would cost a liar. The peacock's tail is useless and metabolically expensive — that's exactly why it's a believable signal of fitness. Apply the same logic to a brand:

  • Advertising spend is itself the message. A big, visible campaign says "we expect to be here long enough to recoup this, and we have repeat customers." A fly-by-night operator can't afford it. The customer doesn't need to read the ad to get the signal.
  • Guarantees, warranties, free returns are costly signals: you'd only offer them if the product actually held up. The cost to you is the proof.
  • Over-delivery and effort ("we'll answer in three rings," lavish packaging, a hand-written note) signal commitment because they obviously cost something.
  • Price can be the feature. For Veblen goods (champagne, perfume, premium tools), a higher price increases desirability and even perceived performance — the expensive placebo genuinely works better. Cutting the price can destroy the signal.

The Pratfall Effect (the honest-flaw signal)

Admitting a real weakness is a costly, hard-to-fake move — so it reads as honesty, and honesty raises trust in everything else you say.

  • Avis: "We're number two. We try harder." Owning the weakness made the brand more likeable and more credible than claiming to be the best.
  • "It's ugly, but it works." / "We're not the cheapest, but here's why." A small genuine flaw makes the rest believable. Perfection reads as marketing; an admitted flaw reads as a person.

How to apply

  1. Read your current signal. Forget what you say — what do your actions cost you, and therefore prove? Cheap claims ("trusted," "premium," "#1") prove nothing.
  2. Find a signal a liar couldn't afford. A guarantee that would bankrupt you if the product were bad. Visible, sustained presence. Effort the customer can see. Real expertise on display.
  3. Consider price as a signal, not just a cost. If trust/desire is the problem, a higher price plus a costlier-looking presentation can outperform a discount. Test before assuming cheaper wins.
  4. Add one honest flaw (Pratfall). State a real limitation plainly. It buys credibility for every true claim around it. Never invent a fake flaw — that's just another cheap claim.
  5. Make sure the signal is honest. A costly signal works because it's tied to reality (you really will honour the guarantee, you really are committed). Faking it is expensive to you and fatal when discovered.

日本語の使用例

  • 「広告にお金をかける意味がわからない、クリックも測れない」→ 広告は支出そのものがシグナル。"これだけ出せる=続く会社/リピートがある" と無意識に伝わる。直接効果だけで測ると本質を外す。
  • 「強気の価格にすると売れなくなる気がする」→ 信頼・憧れが課題なら値下げはシグナルを壊す。高い価格+それに見合う見せ方の方が効くことがある(ヴェブレン財)。counterintuitive-tests で検証。
  • 「完璧に良く見せたいのに刺さらない」→ プラットフォール効果。本当の弱点を1つ正直に開示すると、残りの主張全部の信頼が上がる。
  • 葬儀/シニア領域:「安心してもらいたい」→ "安心です" と言う(安い主張)のではなく、追加料金ゼロの明朗会計・返金保証・24時間必ず人が出る など "嘘つきには払えないコスト" を提示する。

Cross-check against the canon

Sanity-check any proposed signal against these; if it contradicts one, name the contradiction and justify it. When a claim is load-bearing or the user asks for evidence or fresh examples, web-search the named theory or case and cite what you find.

  • Amotz Zahavi, the handicap principle — the biology: a signal is honest because it's costly to fake. If your proposed signal is cheap to imitate, it isn't a signal.
  • Michael Spence, signalling theory — signals work when they're cheaper for honest senders than for liars; check the cost asymmetry, not just the cost.
  • Thorstein Veblen, conspicuous consumption — for status goods, price is the display; discounting can destroy the product's actual function.
  • Elliot Aronson, the pratfall effect (1966) — the caveat: an admitted flaw raises trust only when competence is already established. A struggling brand admitting flaws just looks weak — build the credibility signal first.

Related skills

  • psycho-logic — the router; confirm trust/desire (not meaning) is the real problem
  • reframing — if the issue is meaning rather than credibility, change the frame instead
  • counterintuitive-tests — test price-as-signal and pratfall copy before rolling out
  • marketing-psychology — authority bias, social proof, scarcity, loss aversion in detail (separate plugin — only if installed)

Reviews

No reviews yet. Tell others what you thought.

Comments

No login needed. Share how it worked for you, ask a question, or note where it did not run.

No comments yet. Be the first to write one.

Comments are published right away. Do not include personal information such as email addresses or phone numbers. Up to 2 URLs.

0 / 1,000 characters

This form is protected by reCAPTCHA, and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

More skills from this repository

Generate ideas that don't sound logical, then validate them with cheap behavioural experiments — Rory Sutherland's 'the opposite of a good idea can be a good idea' plus revealed-preference testing. Use when the obvious/logical solution is saturated and the user wants genuinely different options, asks 'what's a creative/unconventional angle', 'how do we stand out', 'should we run a test/experiment', 'how do we know what people actually want', or is about to trust a survey/focus group. Covers deliberate inversion of the obvious move, why stated preferences lie, and designing small reversible experiments that watch behaviour. Inspired by Rory Sutherland's *Alchemy*. Routed to from psycho-logic. 日本語の相談(「競合と同じ案しか出ない」「アンケートは好評なのに売れない」「思い切った案を安く試したい」)にも使う。中文咨询(“只能想出和竞品一样的方案”“问卷好评却卖不动”)也适用。

The English summary is being prepared. Showing the original description.

meikocho1/alchemy-marketing-skills4Updated Sep 25, 2026

The perception-by-culture lens for psycho-logic — establish HOW a specific region, country, or subculture reads a signal before you send it, because perception is culturally coded and the same move can mean the opposite elsewhere. Use when adapting a product, price, message, or campaign to a new market; when the user asks 'will this work in [country/region]', 'why does this land in X but flop in Y', 'how do people here perceive Z', 'how do we localise/differentiate by region', or is about to copy a US/global playbook into another market. Covers the cultural dimensions that move Sutherland's levers — uncertainty avoidance, individualism/collectivism, status/power distance, high- vs low-context communication, mental-accounting norms, trust locus, and taboo/sacredness — and how each rewires reframing, costly-signaling, and experience-design. Inspired by Rory Sutherland's *Alchemy*. Routed to from psycho-logic; pair with market-recon for live local data. 日本語・中文の相談(「この地域で通用する?」「适合本地市场吗?」)にも使う。

The English summary is being prepared. Showing the original description.

meikocho1/alchemy-marketing-skills4Updated Sep 25, 2026

Fix the psychologically significant moment, not the logically significant metric — Rory Sutherland on experience. Use when the outcome is fine but the journey feels bad: complaints about waiting, anxiety, uncertainty, or 'it's technically fast/cheap/correct but people still hate it'; when the user asks 'how do we reduce complaints', 'how do we make waiting/onboarding/checkout feel better', 'people are anxious during X', or is about to spend big to shave a number (wait time, load time, steps) when the real pain is how the moment feels. Covers uncertainty reduction, idle vs occupied waiting, and the peak-end rule. Inspired by Rory Sutherland's *Alchemy*. Routed to from psycho-logic. 日本語の相談(「待ち時間のクレームが多い」「手続きの途中で離脱される」「お客様を不安にさせている」)にも使う。中文咨询(“等待时间投诉多”“办理中途流失”“让客户感到不安”)也适用。

The English summary is being prepared. Showing the original description.

meikocho1/alchemy-marketing-skills4Updated Sep 25, 2026

The live fieldwork layer for psycho-logic — go look at the actual target market NOW instead of reasoning from your training-data stereotype of it. Use when a psycho-logic move needs grounding in a specific place: the user asks 'what do competitors in [region/country] actually do', 'what's the real price band / norm here', 'how do local leaders position themselves', 'research this market before we localise', 'what signals trust to buyers in X', or is about to launch/adapt in a market you haven't studied. Runs structured web research in the local language — local competitors and their signals, price bands, category conventions, review/trust sources, local terminology, taboos and regulations — and synthesises a compact perception profile the four moves consume. Inspired by Rory Sutherland's *Alchemy*. Routed to from psycho-logic; pair with cultural-context (the lens that tells you what to look for). 日本語・中文の相談(「現地の実態を調べて」「调研当地市场」)にも使う。

The English summary is being prepared. Showing the original description.

meikocho1/alchemy-marketing-skills4Updated Sep 25, 2026

Rory Sutherland's 'psycho-logic' approach to marketing, product, and business problems — solve the human perception, not just the engineering or economic metric. Use when the obvious 'logical' fix is expensive, slow, or already done by every competitor; when the user asks 'how do we make people want X', 'the product/price/funnel is fine but nobody converts', 'how do we stand out', 'is there a cheaper way to fix this', or mentions behavioral economics, nudges, irrational behavior, perception, or 'it doesn't make sense but it works'. This is the ROUTER skill: it diagnoses the problem in human terms, then dispatches to reframing, costly-signaling, counterintuitive-tests, or experience-design. Inspired by Rory Sutherland's book *Alchemy*. 日本語の相談(「商品はいいのに売れない」「値下げしかない?」「競合と差別化できない」)にも使う。中文咨询(“产品很好却卖不动”“只能降价吗?”“无法差异化”)也适用。For a catalogue of individual biases, use marketing-psychology (separate plugin) instead.

The English summary is being prepared. Showing the original description.

meikocho1/alchemy-marketing-skills4Updated Sep 25, 2026

Change what something MEANS before you change what it IS — Rory Sutherland's cheapest lever. Use when a product, price, feature, or message is objectively fine but feels cheap, generic, boring, overpriced, or unjustified; when the user says 'how do we make this feel more premium/valuable/exciting', 'people don't get why it's worth it', 'how do we reposition/rename/repackage this', or wants to raise perceived value without changing the product or cutting the price. Covers renaming, recategorising, mental accounting (price framing), creating artificial value, and context-shifting. Inspired by Rory Sutherland's *Alchemy*. Routed to from psycho-logic. 日本語の相談(「高いと言われる」「安っぽく見える」「値下げせずに高級感を出したい」)にも使う。中文咨询(“被说太贵”“显得廉价”“不降价也想显得高级”)也适用。

The English summary is being prepared. Showing the original description.

meikocho1/alchemy-marketing-skills4Updated Sep 25, 2026

See all skills by meikocho1

Report a problem with this skill