Review a design across five areas: visual execution, fit to the user's problem, brand consistency, accessibility, and wording. It guides the agent to fix concrete defects and explain any issues that remain unresolved.
Five-dimension design quality review — score the artifact against craft, brand, accessibility, and copy, then fix what falls short before handing it over.
critique-theater reviews a design from five perspectives and proceeds to fix the defects it finds. It checks visual execution, such as layout and spacing; whether the design solves the requested problem; consistency with the brand; accessibility so people can use it; and the specificity and readability of its text. Each area is checked independently, rather than judging the work only by how attractive it looks.
Use it before handing over a finished design when you want to reduce overlooked issues. It brings together checks for the design system's typography and color requirements, keyboard operation, and explanatory text that contains vague wording or unnecessary padding. This makes it useful when the work needs a review covering both its appearance and how people use and read it.
There are no special notes.
This overview was written by AI (OpenAI Codex) from the public SKILL.md. Check the original below for the exact behavior.
AI rated this skill on four points using only the contents of its SKILL.md. Stars and popularity are not taken into account.
The total counts each point as A = 25, B = 15, C = 5. Rated by AI (OpenAI Codex) as of Oct 20, 2026. Treat it as a guide and read the original before installing.
Review the instructions the agent will receive before you install.
Before you hand an artifact over, review it against five dimensions and fix what falls short. This is a quality bar, not a performance: do the review, apply the fixes, and describe the outcome in ordinary prose.
Judge the artifact you just produced from five angles. Each one owns its own scope; do not let a strength in one excuse a failure in another.
Record each concrete defect and fix it in the same turn. A finding you cannot fix is worth stating plainly, with the reason, so the user can decide.
Keep iterating while defects remain and you still have room to work. Stop when the artifact clears all five dimensions, or when further rounds stop producing real improvements — whichever comes first. Three passes is a sensible ceiling.
OD_MAX_DEVLOOP_ITERATIONS caps the outer plugin pipeline stage; it is not
this review's round limit. A pipeline's critique.score signal is a
scheduler-facing projection, not something you should write into your answer.
Write the outcome the way you would write any other part of your answer: plain prose, in the user's language, saying what you checked, what you fixed, and anything you deliberately left alone.
Do not invent a structured review transcript, a scored panel, a cast of named
reviewer personas, or any tag-based envelope around your answer. Do not write a
critique.json file into the project. None of those are inputs to anything —
they only add noise to the user's chat.
No reviews yet. Tell others what you thought.
No login needed. Share how it worked for you, ask a question, or note where it did not run.
No comments yet. Be the first to write one.
Create a three-scene video composition in a retro pixel style using a Hyperframes HTML template. Customize titles, labels, and colors while preserving scene transitions, short scene durations, and repeatable animation timing.
Create and revise headlines, descriptions, and main text for paid social and search ads. Use it to develop ad copy options and refine wording through repeated rounds of revision.
Create a three-page editorial motion sequence with dark backgrounds, serif typography, staged text reveals, and chapter transitions. The result is a single HTML file suited to fashion-inspired storytelling and short visual presentations.
Inspect and test web pages through a browser automation command-line tool. Navigate, click, enter text, capture screenshots, and extract page details, with a focus on checking local OpenDesign previews and reviewing web app quality.
Plan an AI music album from its concept through lyric drafts, track order, and export. Intended for independent album experiments and brand soundtracks, with the full production workflow provided through a separately installed upstream bundle.
Create generative art, or images made with programmed rules, using p5.js. Fixed random seeds make each rendering reproducible, supporting procedural posters, still images that suggest motion, and studies of artistic frame composition.