Skip to content
cccskills
FreePublished on GitHub

rubric-writer

Use when `paper-review` has claims plus evidence gaps and needs the final referee-style report.

The English summary is being prepared. Showing the original description.

Run score Not tested

See how to install

Files included (2)

  • SKILL.md1.4 KB
  • scripts/run.py3.8 KB

SKILL.md (original)

Review the instructions the agent will receive before you install.

Rubric Writer

Triggers & routing

  • Trigger: rubric review, referee report, peer review write-up, 审稿报告, REVIEW.md.
  • Use when: paper-review pipeline 的最后阶段(C3),已有 output/CLAIMS.md + output/MISSING_EVIDENCE.md(以及可选 novelty matrix)。

Transforms review evidence artifacts into the final paper-review deliverable.

Inputs

Required:

  • output/CLAIMS.md
  • output/MISSING_EVIDENCE.md

Optional:

  • output/NOVELTY_MATRIX.md
  • DECISIONS.md

Output

  • output/REVIEW.md

Contract

The review must expose stable sections:

  • ### Summary
  • ### Novelty
  • ### Soundness
  • ### Clarity
  • ### Impact
  • ### Major Concerns
  • ### Minor Comments
  • ### Recommendation

Every major concern must cite its claim_id or gap_id. This is the traceability interface consumed by the paper-review scorecard.

Script boundary

scripts/run.py should:

  • read prior review artifacts
  • render the stable rubric sections
  • keep the review bounded and traceable

It should not re-parse the manuscript from scratch or perform retrieval.

Acceptance

  • output/REVIEW.md exists
  • includes all stable rubric sections
  • recommendation is explicit

Non-goals

  • deep manuscript parsing
  • novelty retrieval
  • writing an author rebuttal

Reviews

No reviews yet. Tell others what you thought.

Comments

No login needed. Share how it worked for you, ask a question, or note where it did not run.

No comments yet. Be the first to write one.

Comments are published right away. Do not include personal information such as email addresses or phone numbers. Up to 2 URLs.

0 / 1,000 characters

This form is protected by reCAPTCHA, and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

More skills from this repository

Internal template for creating or refactoring a skill into the repository's reference-first shape. **Trigger**: reference-first template, blueprint skill, create a reusable skill, refactor a script-heavy skill. **Use when**: you need a lean `SKILL.md`, explicit `references/`, machine-readable `assets/`, and a minimal deterministic `run.py`.

The English summary is being prepared. Showing the original description.

WILLOSCAR/research-units-pipeline-skills515Updated Oct 5, 2026

Download a small corpus of open-access arXiv survey/review PDFs about agentic systems and extract text for style learning.

The English summary is being prepared. Showing the original description.

WILLOSCAR/research-units-pipeline-skills515Updated Oct 5, 2026

Extract per-subsection “anchor facts” (NO PROSE) from evidence packs so the writer is forced to include concrete numbers/benchmarks/limitations instead of generic summaries.

The English summary is being prepared. Showing the original description.

WILLOSCAR/research-units-pipeline-skills515Updated Oct 5, 2026

Curate reader-facing survey tables for the Appendix (clean layout + high information density), using only in-scope evidence and existing citation keys.

The English summary is being prepared. Showing the original description.

WILLOSCAR/research-units-pipeline-skills515Updated Oct 5, 2026

Build a final, machine-readable argument snapshot from current H3 sections and refresh section fingerprints before merge.

The English summary is being prepared. Showing the original description.

WILLOSCAR/research-units-pipeline-skills515Updated Oct 5, 2026

Audit one research Workspace for declared Unit outputs and Pipeline target Artifacts, writing `output/CONTRACT_REPORT.md`; use for mid-Run coverage snapshots or final delivery completeness, not deep provenance integrity.

The English summary is being prepared. Showing the original description.

WILLOSCAR/research-units-pipeline-skills515Updated Oct 5, 2026

See all skills by WILLOSCAR

Report a problem with this skill