본문으로 건너뛰기
cccskills
무료GitHub에 공개

grafema-haskell-binary-stale-priority

Fix stale Haskell analyzer binaries silently being used by the orchestrator even after a successful rebuild. Use when: (1) modified `packages/js-analyzer/` or other Haskell analyzer source, ran `scripts/build-native.sh ... cabal install`, but a subsequent `grafema analyze` shows old behavior (missing new edges, no new node types, etc.), (2) `~/.cabal/bin/grafema-analyzer` has fresh timestamp but `grafema analyze` produces output as if the change didn't happen, (3) a test verifying new analyzer output passes locally in unit tests but fails in end-to-end runs that go through the orchestrator. Root cause: the Rust orchestrator's `resolve_binary` checks `~/.grafema/bin/<name>` BEFORE `~/.cabal/bin/<name>`, so any stale copy that was once installed there (possibly months ago) shadows the fresh `cabal install` output.

한국어 요약은 준비 중입니다. 원문 설명을 표시하고 있습니다.

설치 방법 보기

포함된 파일(1)

  • SKILL.md4.6 KB

SKILL.md(원문)

설치하기 전에 에이전트에게 전달되는 지시 내용을 확인할 수 있습니다.

Stale Haskell binary in ~/.grafema/bin shadows fresh ~/.cabal/bin

Problem

The Grafema orchestrator looks for Haskell analyzer binaries in ~/.grafema/bin/ BEFORE ~/.cabal/bin/. After running scripts/build-native.sh packages/js-analyzer cabal install --install-method=copy --overwrite-policy=always, the freshly-built binary lands in ~/.cabal/bin/grafema-analyzer, but if a copy was previously placed in ~/.grafema/bin/ (e.g., months ago), the orchestrator picks that one up instead. End-to-end tests then run with the old analyzer, and the symptom is that source-level changes appear "to work" in unit tests but produce zero effect in grafema analyze output.

Context / Trigger Conditions

  • Modified Haskell source in packages/js-analyzer/, packages/grafema-resolve/, packages/python-analyzer/, or any Haskell analyzer package.
  • Ran scripts/build-native.sh <pkg> cabal install ... and saw "build succeeded".
  • Ran grafema analyze (or end-to-end test) and the new behavior is missing — no new edge type, no new node type, etc.
  • Unit tests against the newly-built ~/.cabal/bin/<binary> directly DO show the new behavior.
  • ls -la ~/.cabal/bin/<binary> shows fresh mtime, ls -la ~/.grafema/bin/<binary> shows OLD mtime (the smoking gun).

Solution

After cabal install (or any binary rebuild), force-update ~/.grafema/bin/ with the fresh binary:

cp ~/.cabal/bin/grafema-analyzer ~/.grafema/bin/grafema-analyzer
cp ~/.cabal/bin/grafema-resolve ~/.grafema/bin/grafema-resolve
# ...for each affected binary

Or symlink once and forget:

ln -sf ~/.cabal/bin/grafema-analyzer ~/.grafema/bin/grafema-analyzer

Permanent fix candidates (not done at the time of writing — see follow-up task): change scripts/build-native.sh to also update ~/.grafema/bin/ after cabal install, OR change the orchestrator's resolve_binary to prefer ~/.cabal/bin/ when its mtime is newer than ~/.grafema/bin/'s, OR refuse to use ~/.grafema/bin/ when its .build-hash doesn't match the source hash.

Verification

# 1. Source hash updated
cat packages/js-analyzer/.build-hash

# 2. Both binaries point to recent build
ls -la ~/.cabal/bin/grafema-analyzer ~/.grafema/bin/grafema-analyzer
# Both timestamps should be from the recent build

# 3. End-to-end test
node packages/cli/dist/cli.js analyze
# Verify the new edge type / node type now appears in the graph

Example

During Library Callback Resolver work (April 2026), Change 3 added a RECEIVER_CALL edge to the JS analyzer. cabal install succeeded. End-to-end verification on Grafema's own codebase produced 0 RECEIVER_CALL edges. After investigation: ~/.cabal/bin/grafema-analyzer was dated April 25; ~/.grafema/bin/grafema-analyzer was dated March 31. After manual cp, the edges appeared correctly and the entire feature pipeline worked end-to-end on the second grafema analyze run.

Notes

  • This issue is more dangerous than a normal stale-build problem because unit tests can pass (they invoke the fresh binary directly) while the orchestrator silently uses the stale copy.
  • The .build-hash sidecar in packages/<pkg>/.build-hash reflects source state but isn't currently checked at runtime against the chosen binary's origin — that's a feature gap (see follow-up task).
  • A user-friendly heuristic during debugging: if a unit-level Haskell test shows X but grafema analyze shows ¬X, suspect binary staleness FIRST, before suspecting a bug in the orchestrator wiring.

References

  • Build script: scripts/build-native.sh
  • Binary resolver: packages/grafema-orchestrator/src/ (search resolve_binary)
  • Memory note: MEMORY.md → "Stale Binary Protection"

리뷰

아직 리뷰가 없습니다. 사용해 본 소감을 남겨 주세요.

댓글

로그인 없이 쓸 수 있습니다. 사용 후기, 질문, 작동하지 않은 환경 등을 편하게 남겨 주세요.

아직 댓글이 없습니다. 첫 댓글을 남겨 보세요.

보내면 바로 공개됩니다. 이메일 주소나 전화번호 같은 개인 정보는 쓰지 마세요. URL은 2개까지입니다.

0 / 1,000자

이 양식은 reCAPTCHA로 보호되며 Google 개인정보처리방침 및 서비스 약관이 적용됩니다.

같은 저장소의 스킬

Fix Elixir/Erlang AST processing bugs in Grafema beam-analyzer. Use when: (1) Elixir parser returns MODULE node but 0 functions/calls — body nesting issue, (2) Erlang parser crashes with "cannot convert list to string" on OTP 26+ — location format changed from integer to keyword list, (3) pipe operator |> creates spurious CALL nodes instead of desugared function calls — clause ordering bug, (4) multi-module .ex files return only the first module — missing __block__ handler, (5) installing Erlang/Elixir on macOS with outdated Xcode/Clang.

한국어 요약은 준비 중입니다. 원문 설명을 표시하고 있습니다.

Disentinel/grafema352026년 8월 24일 업데이트

Fires after fixing any non-trivial bug or regression. Asks: could the graph have caught this as a guarantee? Pairs with reflection-in-and-on-action — picks up after "earliest catchable signal" and asks the next question: was that signal expressible in graph? Triggers: (1) after any non-trivial bug fix is verified working, (2) after a regression report (something used to work, broke), (3) during step 6 (knowledge extraction) of the workflow, (4) when reflection-on-action surfaces a "would have been catchable" signal. Outcome is a triage decision (graph-reachable? rule expressible? rule sound?) and either a draft Linear issue + guarantee proposal, or a recorded "graph capability gap" note. Never auto-creates guarantees.

한국어 요약은 준비 중입니다. 원문 설명을 표시하고 있습니다.

Disentinel/grafema352026년 8월 24일 업데이트

Fix Playwright automation failures against code-server (VS Code in browser). Use when: (1) trust dialog blocks all clicks — "monaco-dialog-modal-block intercepts pointer events", (2) button:has-text() finds wrong buttons behind modal dialog, (3) keyboard shortcuts don't work — Meta vs Control inconsistency, (4) VS Code extension activity bar icon not found by aria-label, (5) panels show placeholder text despite extension being "Connected". Covers trust dialog dismissal, keyboard shortcut hybrid mode, extension panel selectors, and database connection verification for Grafema extension.

한국어 요약은 준비 중입니다. 원문 설명을 표시하고 있습니다.

Disentinel/grafema352026년 8월 24일 업데이트

Systematic methodology for achieving 100% backward dataflow reachability in a new language. Create gauntlet fixture, write trace, diagnose gaps, fix analyzer/algorithm, iterate to 100%. Language-agnostic process. Use when: (1) adding a new language to Grafema, (2) auditing dataflow coverage for existing language, (3) user says "/dataflow-gauntlet".

한국어 요약은 준비 중입니다. 원문 설명을 표시하고 있습니다.

Disentinel/grafema352026년 8월 24일 업데이트

Fix docker exec hanging when starting background processes (servers, daemons) inside containers. Use when: (1) docker exec never returns despite using & or nohup, (2) background server started in container causes docker exec to hang indefinitely, (3) env_startup_command in SWE-bench or similar frameworks times out, (4) setsid/disown needed for proper process detachment in Docker. Root cause: docker exec tracks ALL processes in the exec session, not just the top-level PID.

한국어 요약은 준비 중입니다. 원문 설명을 표시하고 있습니다.

Disentinel/grafema352026년 8월 24일 업데이트

Fix Node.js CLI tools crashing inside Docker containers when host-installed node_modules require a newer Node version than the container provides. Use when: (1) "SyntaxError: Invalid regular expression flags" with /v flag in string-width or similar packages, (2) node_modules installed on host with Node 20+ but container has Node 18, (3) `npm install` with file: protocol creates symlinks that break inside Docker, (4) pnpm workspace packages become broken symlinks in containers. Covers version detection, Node binary mounting, and npm install strategies for cross-version compatibility.

한국어 요약은 준비 중입니다. 원문 설명을 표시하고 있습니다.

Disentinel/grafema352026년 8월 24일 업데이트

Disentinel의 스킬 모두 보기

이 스킬의 문제 신고