Closed-Form Marbling Renderer

Render real marbling the way Lu & Jaffer proved you can (IEEE CG&A 32(6), 2012): not by simulating fluid, but by treating the marbling tray as a set of colored region boundaries and applying each tool as a closed-form homeomorphism of the plane to every boundary point at once. A finished marble is just a composition Tn ∘ … ∘ T1 of these maps. Pure arithmetic, O(points) per op, 60fps.

When to use / when NOT

• Use to implement drop / tine / comb / wave / swirl ops, to script the four canonical Ebru patterns, to keep combed lines crisp, to model ox-gall, or to lift a high-res print off the tray.
• Do NOT reach for a fluid solver, reaction-diffusion, metaballs, or alpha-blended translucent disks. Those produce blurry "smoke goo," not the crisp veined cells of real Ebru, and they don't compose, replay, or scale to print.

Core mental model

flowchart LR
  S["State<br/>ops[] + regions[]"] --> D{Tool}
  D -->|drop| P["push ALL prior verts<br/>radially, then add<br/>fresh color circle"]
  D -->|tine / wave / swirl| W["warp ALL verts<br/>(closed form)"]
  W --> R["adaptive resample<br/>(keep edges crisp)"]
  P --> M["live regions"]
  R --> M
  M -->|painter's algo| C["Canvas2D (60fps)"]
  S -->|replay at print res| X["High-DPI PNG export"]

Four invariants that make this faithful instead of generic:

1. Boundaries, not pixels. Each color region is a closed polyline; tools move vertices. Smooth maps applied to dense polylines look like smooth dye.
2. Drops shoulder, they don't blend. A new drop physically pushes earlier ink aside (the radial map), so fills stay opaque and you get crisp ring-in-ring.
3. Everything composes. State is an ordered op list; you can replay, undo, serialize, and re-render at any resolution from the same script.
4. Resample under combing. Comb maps stretch segments a lot; subdivide or edges go faceted.

---

The deformation algebra (copy-paste)

All functions take/return {x, y} and are pure. regions = [{ pts:[{x,y}…], color }], oldest first (paint order). Coordinates are in logical tray pixels.

1. Ink drop — radial outward push (area-preserving)

P' = C + (P − C) · sqrt( 1 + r² / ‖P − C‖² )

This is why nested drops form perfect concentric bullseyes: it maps circles to circles and is area-preserving away from C. The only singularity is a vertex exactly at C — guard with epsilon.

// Push one point away from drop center C with disk radius r.
function dropPush(P, C, r) {
  const dx = P.x - C.x, dy = P.y - C.y;
  const d2 = dx * dx + dy * dy;
  const s = Math.sqrt(1 + (r * r) / Math.max(d2, 1e-6)); // epsilon guards C
  return { x: C.x + dx * s, y: C.y + dy * s };
}

// A full drop op: shoulder every prior vertex aside, then float a new color disk.
function applyDrop(regions, C, r, color, segs = 128) {
  for (const reg of regions) reg.pts = reg.pts.map((P) => dropPush(P, C, r));
  const ring = [];
  for (let i = 0; i < segs; i++) {
    const a = (i / segs) * 2 * Math.PI;
    ring.push({ x: C.x + r * Math.cos(a), y: C.y + r * Math.sin(a) });
  }
  regions.push({ pts: ring, color }); // newest on top (painter order)
}

2. Tine / comb — drag parallel to a line, decaying with perpendicular distance

general: P' = P + t̂ · z · u^|d|, where d = (P − L) · n̂ vertical tine at xL: (x, y + z·u^|x−xL|) horizontal tine at yL: (x + z·u^|y−yL|, y)

t̂ = unit drag direction, n̂ = its normal, z = max displacement (sign = drag direction; flip it for the tidal reversal), u ∈ (0,1) = sharpness/viscosity (u^|d| decays away from the line). Lower u = tighter, crisper comb lines; u→1 = broad smear.

// t = unit tangent {x,y}; displacement is symmetric in |d| but always along +t.
function tineShear(P, L, t, u, z) {
  const nx = -t.y, ny = t.x;                       // unit normal
  const d = (P.x - L.x) * nx + (P.y - L.y) * ny;   // signed perp distance
  const amt = z * Math.pow(u, Math.abs(d));
  return { x: P.x + t.x * amt, y: P.y + t.y * amt };
}
// A "rake" = N parallel tines: call tineShear once per L = base + i*spacing*n̂.

3. Serpentine wave — horizontal shift set by y (basis for Şal S-curves)

Wh(x, y) = ( x − A·sin(k·y + φ), y )

A = amplitude, k = spatial frequency in radians per pixel (wavelength λ = 2π/k), φ = phase (offset successive passes to braid). CSAIL's reference values are A≈20, λ≈140px. Chain Wh then Wv for a woven "peacock" texture; run the wave opposite the last tidal direction for an authentic Şal.

function waveWarp(P, A, k, phase) {
  return { x: P.x - A * Math.sin(k * P.y + phase), y: P.y };
}

4. Swirl / vortex — decaying rotation about a center (Bülbül Yuvası nests)

α(d) = θ₀ · e^(−d/ρ), then rotate (P − C) by α(d) about C.

Same decay idea as the tine, but the displacement is angular instead of linear. θ₀ = peak swirl at center, ρ = falloff radius (equivalently ρ = −1/ln u). Strong near the center, fading out → a tight spiral = a nightingale's nest.

function swirl(P, C, theta0, rho) {
  const dx = P.x - C.x, dy = P.y - C.y;
  const a = theta0 * Math.exp(-Math.hypot(dx, dy) / rho);
  const ca = Math.cos(a), sa = Math.sin(a);
  return { x: C.x + dx * ca - dy * sa, y: C.y + dx * sa + dy * ca };
}

5. Adaptive resampling — the crispness keeper

Comb/wave/swirl maps stretch boundaries; without resampling, long segments go faceted (polygonal "lightning bolt" edges). After every warp pass, subdivide any segment longer than maxSeg. Cap total points with optional decimation so the frame budget stays bounded.

function resample(pts, maxSeg) {           // closed polyline
  const out = [], n = pts.length;
  for (let i = 0; i < n; i++) {
    const a = pts[i], b = pts[(i + 1) % n];
    out.push(a);
    const len = Math.hypot(b.x - a.x, b.y - a.y);
    if (len > maxSeg) {
      const k = Math.ceil(len / maxSeg);
      for (let j = 1; j < k; j++) {
        const t = j / k;
        out.push({ x: a.x + (b.x - a.x) * t, y: a.y + (b.y - a.y) * t });
      }
    }
  }
  return out;
}

6. Ox-gall shouldering — radius schedule

Ox-gall (öd) is the surfactant that makes a drop spread into a disk and push earlier colors aside — and each successive drop spreads slightly less (earlier films resist it). You do not model this with extra blending; the §1 push is the shouldering. Just decay the radius of later drops and expose gall as a slider that scales the base radius.

function gallRadius(baseR, gall, priorDrops) {   // gall slider ∈ [0.4, 1.6]
  return baseR * gall * Math.pow(0.985, priorDrops);
}

---

Composition: the op list is the marble

State is { regions: [], ops: [] }. Mutate regions live for 60fps; use full replay() only for undo (pop op, replay) and export (replay at print resolution). Serializing ops (+ the PRNG seed) makes any marble reproducible and shareable.

function warpFor(op) {                            // op → vertex map
  if (op.t === 'tine')  return (P) => tineShear(P, op.L, op.dir, op.u, op.z);
  if (op.t === 'wave')  return (P) => waveWarp(P, op.A, op.k, op.phase);
  if (op.t === 'swirl') return (P) => swirl(P, op.C, op.theta0, op.rho);
}

function replay(ops, { segs = 128, maxSeg = 3 } = {}) {
  const regions = [];
  for (const op of ops) {
    if (op.t === 'drop') {
      applyDrop(regions, op.C, op.r, op.color, segs);
    } else {
      const f = warpFor(op);
      for (const reg of regions) reg.pts = resample(reg.pts.map(f), maxSeg);
    }
  }
  return regions;
}

// Deterministic positions → reproducible marble from a serialized seed.
function mulberry32(seed) {
  return function () {
    let t = (seed += 0x6d2b79f5);
    t = Math.imul(t ^ (t >>> 15), t | 1);
    t ^= t + Math.imul(t ^ (t >>> 7), t | 61);
    return ((t ^ (t >>> 14)) >>> 0) / 4294967296;
  };
}

---

Traditional Ebru pattern scripts

Each pattern is just an ordered push onto ops. They build on each other exactly as a marbler builds on the tray: a Battal ground first, then comb work over it.

// 2.1 BATTAL ("spattered") — the ground. Many interleaved drops, NO comb.
function battal(ops, rng, W, H, pigments, n, gall) {
  const baseR = Math.min(W, H) * 0.06;
  for (let i = 0; i < n; i++)
    ops.push({ t: 'drop', C: { x: rng() * W, y: rng() * H },
               r: gallRadius(baseR, gall, i), color: pigments[i % pigments.length] });
}

// 2.2 GEL-GIT ("tidal") — parallel tine passes marching across x, z flipping sign.
function gelgit(ops, W, H, { spacing = 24, z = 46, u = 0.92 } = {}) {
  let sign = 1;
  for (let xL = spacing; xL < W; xL += spacing) {
    ops.push({ t: 'tine', L: { x: xL, y: 0 }, dir: { x: 0, y: 1 }, u, z: z * sign });
    sign = -sign;                                   // ebb and flow
  }
}

// 2.3 ŞAL ("shawl") — Gel-Git, THEN S-curves opposite the last tidal direction.
function sal(ops, W, H, opts = {}) {
  gelgit(ops, W, H, opts);
  const { A = 18, k = (2 * Math.PI) / 70, passes = 6 } = opts;   // λ ≈ 70px
  for (let p = 0; p < passes; p++)
    ops.push({ t: 'wave', A, k, phase: p * (Math.PI / 3) });
}

// 2.4 BÜLBÜL YUVASI ("nightingale's nest") — small Battal, then a grid of swirls.
function bulbulYuvasi(ops, rng, W, H, pigments, gall,
                      { grid = 120, rho = 42, theta0 = 4.2 } = {}) {
  battal(ops, rng, W, H, pigments, Math.floor((W * H) / (grid * grid)) * 3, gall);
  for (let y = grid / 2; y < H; y += grid)
    for (let x = grid / 2; x < W; x += grid) {
      const jx = x + (rng() - 0.5) * grid * 0.4;    // jitter so nests aren't gridlocked
      const jy = y + (rng() - 0.5) * grid * 0.4;
      ops.push({ t: 'swirl', C: { x: jx, y: jy }, theta0, rho });
    }
}

---

Rendering & period pigments

Paint painter's-algorithm, oldest region first onto a cream "size-water" ground; opaque fills + a thin warm-dark stroke read as the shouldered seam (the vein) where the cream peeks through. Caller sets the device transform; geometry stays in logical coords.

function render(ctx, regions, { W, H, cream, vein, lw = 0.8 }) {
  ctx.fillStyle = cream; ctx.fillRect(0, 0, W, H);          // gum-tragacanth size
  for (const reg of regions) {
    const p = reg.pts;
    ctx.beginPath(); ctx.moveTo(p[0].x, p[0].y);
    for (let i = 1; i < p.length; i++) ctx.lineTo(p[i].x, p[i].y);
    ctx.closePath();
    ctx.fillStyle = reg.color; ctx.fill();
    ctx.lineWidth = lw; ctx.strokeStyle = vein;
    ctx.globalAlpha = 0.35; ctx.stroke(); ctx.globalAlpha = 1; // thin shouldered vein
  }
}

Period pigments (artist-pigment appearance — not the misleading electric CSS "indigo / malachite" names). Pull each slightly toward gray; let cream show in veins.

Pigment	Hex	Note
Indigo (Indigofera)	#1B3B6F	muted desaturated navy, never electric blue
Madder red (Rubia)	#B23B3B	earthy brick-rose, slightly orange
Gamboge yellow	#E8A317	warm saffron-amber, not lemon
Malachite green	#4A8B6F	cool-mid mineral green, slightly grayed
Size-water (cream)	#F1E9D2	warm parchment — "the paper"
Vein / outline	#2A2418	warm near-black for shouldered seams

---

High-DPI export — "lift the paper"

Replay the same op list onto an offscreen canvas at scale×, with a tighter maxSeg (in device px) and denser circles so edges are crisp at print resolution. Then toBlob('image/png') and download. This is the whole reason to keep state as a script: resolution independence is free.

function liftPaper(ops, W, H, theme, scale = 4) {
  const off = document.createElement('canvas');
  off.width = Math.round(W * scale); off.height = Math.round(H * scale);
  const ctx = off.getContext('2d');
  ctx.scale(scale, scale);                                  // draw in logical coords
  const regions = replay(ops, { segs: 256, maxSeg: 2 / scale }); // ~2 device px edges
  render(ctx, regions, { ...theme, W, H, lw: 0.6 / scale });
  off.toBlob((b) => {
    const a = document.createElement('a');
    a.href = URL.createObjectURL(b);
    a.download = 'su-ebru.png'; a.click();
    URL.revokeObjectURL(a.href);
  }, 'image/png');
}

---

Decision frameworks

Which deformation? drop → bloom/ground & bullseyes · tine → straight combed columns (Gel-Git) · wave → S-curve weave (Şal) · swirl → spiral nests (Bülbül Yuvası). Compose freely; order matters (ground before comb).

Knob	Lower value	Higher value	Sane default
u (viscosity)	tight, crisp comb lines	broad smear	0.90–0.94
z (tine drag)	gentle nudge	violent drag, may self-intersect	30–60 px
maxSeg (resample)	crisp but slower	fast but faceted	3 px live / 2/scale print
drop r base	tiny speckle	few fat blobs	~6% of min(W,H)
gall	drops barely spread	drops dominate, thin veins	1.0
swirl ρ	tiny tight nests	wide lazy swirls	~35–45 px

Live vs replay: mutate regions in place per op for interactivity; only replay() for undo and export. Point budget: if a live frame drops below 60fps, raise maxSeg or decimate; do not lower drop segs (that breaks bullseyes).

---

Anti-patterns (Novice → Expert → Timeline)

1. Metaball / fluid-sim "smoke goo."

• Novice: reaches for Navier-Stokes, curl-noise, reaction-diffusion, or metaballs to get "swirly" looks. Result: blurry, blendy, non-deterministic, can't export at print res, and tanks the frame rate.
• Expert: closed-form coordinate deformation of boundaries. Exact, O(points), 60fps, resolution-independent, fully replayable.
• Timeline: pre-2012 marbling demos used fluid solvers; Lu & Jaffer (IEEE CG&A 2012) proved drop+tine maps reproduce real marbling exactly and in real time.

2. Alpha-blended translucent disks instead of the radial push.

• Novice: draws overlapping globalAlpha circles and hopes colors "mix." Gets muddy browns and zero ring-in-ring.
• Expert: applies the §1 push so earlier ink is physically displaced; fills stay opaque; the vein is a seam, not a blend. That's the bullseye.

3. Combing coarse polylines (no resampling).

• Novice: shears a 64-vertex circle and ships faceted, polygonal "lightning" edges.
• Expert: subdivides after every warp so no segment exceeds maxSeg; smooth dye.
• Timeline: the perennial real-time-graphics gotcha — deformation needs vertex density proportional to curvature it induces.

4. Electric CSS pigments + degrees-vs-radians sin.

• Novice: uses #4B0082 "indigo," #0bda51 "malachite," and sin(k*y) with a k meant for degrees. Result: neon toy with the wrong wavelength.
• Expert: muted ground-mineral hexes (table above) and k in radians/px (λ = 2π/k); cream shows through thin veins → reads handmade, not "smoke goo."

5. Unguarded singularity at a drop/swirl center.

• Novice: divides by ‖P−C‖ with no floor → a NaN the instant a vertex lands on a center, and the whole tray explodes.
• Expert: Math.max(d2, 1e-6) epsilon guard on drops; hypot is safe for swirl.

---

Quality checklist

• Three nested drops at the same center render a clean concentric bullseye (drop map correct + area-preserving).
• Combing a Battal yields smooth, non-faceted bands at any zoom (resampling live).
• Flipping tine z sign produces visible tidal back-and-forth (Gel-Git).
• Şal wave runs opposite the final tidal direction; nests in Bülbül Yuvası are jittered, not gridlocked.
• Sustains 60fps at display resolution for a typical op count (live mutation, bounded point budget).
• liftPaper at scale ≥ 4 exports a crisp, valid PNG (tighter maxSeg).
• No NaNs under stress (drop directly on an existing vertex; overlapping swirl centers).
• Pigments are muted minerals, cream shows in veins — never electric.
• Same ops + seed replays identically (serializable, undoable marble).

---

Worked example: a faithful Şal, end to end

const W = 900, H = 1200, gall = 1.0;
const PIG = ['#1B3B6F', '#B23B3B', '#E8A317', '#4A8B6F']; // indigo, madder, gamboge, malachite
const THEME = { cream: '#F1E9D2', vein: '#2A2418' };
const rng = mulberry32(0xEB12);            // seed → reproducible marble

const ops = [];
battal(ops, rng, W, H, PIG, 70, gall);     // 1. stone-like ground; later drops shouldered smaller
gelgit(ops, W, H, { spacing: 26, z: 50, u: 0.92 }); // 2. tidal combed columns (alternating z)
// sal() would add the waves; inline here to show the opposite-direction weave:
const k = (2 * Math.PI) / 70;
for (let p = 0; p < 6; p++) ops.push({ t: 'wave', A: 18, k, phase: p * Math.PI / 3 }); // 3. S-curves

const ctx = canvas.getContext('2d');       // canvas sized W×H (× dpr in real use)
render(ctx, replay(ops, { segs: 160, maxSeg: 3 }), { ...THEME, W, H }); // live preview
// Lift the paper:
liftPaper(ops, W, H, THEME, 4);            // 3600×4800 PNG download

What a novice would ship: translucent blobs over a metaball field, electric blue, faceted comb lines, no export. What this produces: opaque shouldered cells with thin cream veins, smooth interlocked shawl S-curves over tidal columns, deterministic and exportable at print resolution — historically faithful Ebru.

---

NOT-FOR boundaries

• Real fluid simulation (Navier-Stokes, SPH, lattice-Boltzmann) → this skill is explicitly the closed-form alternative; don't import a solver.
• Metaball / blob / "smoke" aesthetics → wrong model, see anti-pattern #1.
• Raster image filters (blur, displacement-map a photo) → this deforms vector boundaries, not pixels.
• Figurative single-stroke marbling (flowers, the "Oseen flow" velocity field, Jaffer's stroke.pdf) → out of scope; this covers the four geometric patterns.
• Non-marbling generative art → use a general creative-coding skill.

Sources

• Lu, Jaffer, Jin, Zhao, Mao — "Mathematical Marbling," IEEE CG&A 32(6):26–35, 2012 (drop + tine + wave + composition).
• Jaffer — MIT CSAIL Marbling pages: Mathematics, Dropping-Paint, Serpentine (axis-aligned Fv/Fh, Wh, reference A/k); stroke.pdf (Oseen flow, out of scope).
• Ebru recipes (Battal / Gel-Git / Şal / Bülbül Yuvası) and ox-gall surfactant shouldering — Turkish Arts; Les Arts Turcs; Marmorierfarben.