跳到正文
cccskills
免费在 GitHub 公开

vcsdd-adversarial-refinement

Use this skill when running or interpreting VCSDD adversarial reviews. Provides calibration guidance for the Adversary agent, finding severity classification, and anti-leniency enforcement patterns.

中文简介正在准备中。当前显示原文说明。

查看安装方法

包含的文件(1)

  • SKILL.md2.7 KB

SKILL.md(原文)

安装前可以查看交给 AI 代理的指令内容。

VCSDD Adversarial Refinement

When to Activate

  • Phase 3 (adversarial review)
  • Interpreting adversary findings
  • Calibrating review intensity

Adversary Calibration Principles

The Adversary MUST:

  1. Never say "overall looks good" or equivalent
  2. Always cite real file paths and line numbers
  3. Always produce a binary PASS or FAIL per dimension
  4. Never soften findings with qualifiers like "minor" or "nitpick"
  5. Always specify routeToPhase for actionable routing

Severity Classification

SeverityDefinitionExamples
criticalPipeline cannot continueMissing spec requirement entirely, security vulnerability
highSignificant defect requiring reworkWrong return type, missing error handling, untested edge case
mediumDefect that reduces qualityMisleading name, unnecessary abstraction, dead code
lowImprovement opportunityStyle inconsistency, minor duplication

Common Leniency Traps

Watch for these patterns and reject them:

  • "The code handles most cases" → HOW MANY? WHICH ONES MISSING?
  • "Error handling is adequate" → ADEQUATE BY WHAT STANDARD?
  • "Generally follows the spec" → WHICH REQUIREMENTS ARE MISSING?
  • "Minor refactoring could help" → IS THIS STRUCTURAL_INTEGRITY FAIL OR NOT?

Finding Routing Guide

CategoryMeaningRoute To
spec_ambiguityRequirement or contract wording is ambiguous1a
spec_gapBehavior exists but spec/contract does not cover it1a
requirement_mismatchSpec is clear, but tests or implementation do not satisfy it2b
missing_edge_caseEdge case absent from spec or tests1a or 2a
test_coverageRequired behavior has no meaningful test2a
test_qualityTautological or over-mocked test, or implementation-detail assertion2a
implementation_bugLogic defect2b
error_handlingIncorrect or missing error path2b
security_surfaceValidation/auth/injection issue2b
code_structureCohesion/abstraction/organization issue2c
namingMisleading or imprecise names2c
duplicationRepeated logic that should be unified2c
proof_gapMissing proof harness or unverifiable claim5
invariant_violationProof/testing evidence contradicts required invariant5
purity_boundarySupposedly pure logic still depends on effects2c or 5

评价

还没有评价。欢迎分享你的使用感受。

评论

无需登录即可发表。欢迎分享使用感受、提问,或说明在哪些环境下无法运行。

还没有评论。来写第一条吧。

提交后会立即公开。请勿填写邮箱、电话等个人信息。URL 最多 2 个。

0 / 1000 字

此表单受 reCAPTCHA 保护,适用 Google 的隐私权政策和服务条款。

同一仓库的技能

Run Phase 3 (adversarial review) for the active VCSDD feature. Spawns a fresh vcsdd-adversary agent with zero Builder context to review implementation against spec. Produces binary PASS/FAIL verdict per dimension.

中文简介正在准备中。当前显示原文说明。

sc30gsw/vcsdd-claude-code272026年4月5日 更新

Create a git commit for the current VCSDD phase. Auto-generates a conventional commit message from state.json including phase, sprint, gate verdict, and affected bead IDs. Tags with vcsdd/<feature>/phase-<id>.

中文简介正在准备中。当前显示原文说明。

sc30gsw/vcsdd-claude-code272026年4月5日 更新

Run the strict-mode sprint contract review after Phase 2c. Spawns a fresh vcsdd-adversary instance to review `contracts/sprint-N.md` and writes a PASS/FAIL verdict under `reviews/contracts/sprint-N/output/`.

中文简介正在准备中。当前显示原文说明。

sc30gsw/vcsdd-claude-code272026年4月5日 更新

Run Phase 6 (convergence check) for the active VCSDD feature. Validates four-dimensional convergence: finding diminishment, finding specificity, criteria coverage, and duplicate detection.

中文简介正在准备中。当前显示原文说明。

sc30gsw/vcsdd-claude-code272026年4月5日 更新

Use this skill during Phase 6 convergence checks. Provides four-dimensional convergence analysis, hallucination detection, and duplicate finding identification.

中文简介正在准备中。当前显示原文说明。

sc30gsw/vcsdd-claude-code272026年4月5日 更新

Architect escalation approval — extend iteration limit for a phase that has hit its cap. Records the approval decision in state and allows the blocked transition to proceed.

中文简介正在准备中。当前显示原文说明。

sc30gsw/vcsdd-claude-code272026年4月5日 更新

查看 sc30gsw 的全部技能

报告此技能的问题