Review dimensions for validating agent quality - template compliance, safety, testing, and priority validation
The English summary is being prepared. Showing the original description.
How the nWave buddy agent reads a project to answer questions — detection, order of inspection, and citation discipline.
The English summary is being prepared. Showing the original description.
See how to installReview the instructions the agent will receive before you install.
The buddy agent answers questions about a project by reading it, not by guessing. Every answer must be traceable to a specific file and line. This skill is the reading protocol.
path:line) so the user can verify.Read in this order. Stop as soon as you have enough context for the current question.
README.md — what is this project, for whom.CLAUDE.md (project root) — how Claude-based tools should behave here.pyproject.toml / package.json / Cargo.toml / equivalent — language, dependencies, versions, scripts.VERSION or the version field in the package manifest.These four files tell you the project's name, language, purpose, and roughly how big it is. Skip nothing here.
BACKLOG.md — the single source of truth for planned work (in nWave projects).CHANGELOG.md — recent user-visible changes.git status — what's in flight right now.git log --oneline -20 — recent direction of travel.If the user's question is "what should I work on next" or "what did we just do", these four are usually the answer.
docs/architecture/architecture-design.md (or similar SSOT file).docs/adrs/ — Architecture Decision Records.docs/feature/ — feature specs with wave subdirectories.The architecture doc is authoritative for design intent. If a claim in the architecture doc contradicts the code, the code is what runs — but the mismatch is itself a finding worth reporting.
ls the top-level dirs.ls src/ (or the project's source root).main.py, index.ts, Main.fs, etc.).A project's directory layout tells you 80% of its architecture in a few seconds: domain/, application/, adapters/, ports/, tests/ means hexagonal. src/, views/, controllers/, models/ means MVC. core/, api/, ui/ means layered.
tests/ or equivalent — top-level directories only, initially.conftest.py / test config — tells you how tests are organized and marked.Tests often document behavior more precisely than prose docs.
Once the question is clear, read the specific files it touches. Don't pre-load.
Answer these as you read:
nWave/ directory, framework-catalog.yaml, BACKLOG.md at root, agents/commands/skills layout, mentions of waves in docs.pyproject.toml, package.json, .csproj, build.sbt, etc.git status or git branch --show-current. Branch name often encodes the current focus.CODEOWNERS if present.Record the answers silently; draw on them when answering.
When reading a feature to answer "what's next?", check for these wave artifacts in order:
| Wave | Artifact Path | Existence Check |
|---|---|---|
| DIVERGE | docs/feature/{id}/diverge/recommendation.md | Branch point recommendation exists |
| DISCUSS | docs/feature/{id}/discuss/user-stories.md | User stories written |
| DESIGN | docs/feature/{id}/design/wave-decisions.md | Architecture decisions documented |
| DEVOPS | docs/feature/{id}/devops/wave-decisions.md | CI/CD and deployment decisions documented |
| DISTILL | tests/{test-type-path}/{id}/acceptance/*.feature | BDD test scenarios written (the .feature file is the SSOT) |
| DELIVER | docs/feature/{id}/deliver/roadmap.json | All implementation steps at COMMIT/PASS |
Stop at the first missing artifact — that's where the feature currently is. For features using the old flat model (no wave subdirectories), treat as pre-DIVERGE.
Every concrete claim in an answer must point to a source:
src/des/data/workflows/tdd-deliver.yaml:12)"docs/architecture/architecture-design.md section 3"feature/foo (from git status)"If you're paraphrasing, still cite. If you're guessing, say "I don't see this in the files I've read" and stop — don't fabricate.
When a citation would be noise (trivial claims like "this is a Python project"), omit it. When a claim is load-bearing, always cite.
node_modules/, .venv/, build/, dist/, target/, lock files (unless the question is about deps).If the user's question requires reading more than ~15 files, or requires running commands, or touches a part of the codebase you can't reach, say so explicitly. Offer a plan: "to answer this I would need to read X, Y, Z — proceed?"
A well-formed answer:
README.md, pyproject.toml, CLAUDE.md — get the elevator pitch and version.BACKLOG.md — get the current priorities.git status + git log --oneline -10 — get the current branch and recent direction.<name> v<version>, a <one-sentence purpose> written in <language>. The current branch is <branch>. Recent commits focus on <summary>. The backlog's top items are <top 3>. (citations for each claim)"Total reading: 4-5 files, under a minute. That's the standard to aim for.
No reviews yet. Tell others what you thought.
No login needed. Share how it worked for you, ask a question, or note where it did not run.
No comments yet. Be the first to write one.
Review dimensions for validating agent quality - template compliance, safety, testing, and priority validation
The English summary is being prepared. Showing the original description.
Review dimensions for validating agent quality - template compliance, safety, testing, and priority validation
The English summary is being prepared. Showing the original description.
Review dimensions for acceptance test quality - happy path bias, GWT compliance, business language purity, coverage completeness, walking skeleton user-centricity, priority validation, observable behavior assertions, traceability coverage, and walking skeleton boundary proof
The English summary is being prepared. Showing the original description.
Detailed 5-phase workflow for creating agents - from requirements analysis through validation and iterative refinement
The English summary is being prepared. Showing the original description.
5-layer testing approach for agent validation including adversarial testing, security validation, and prompt injection resistance
The English summary is being prepared. Showing the original description.
Architectural style selection decision matrices, trade-off analysis, structural enforcement rules, and combination patterns. Load when choosing or evaluating architecture styles.
The English summary is being prepared. Showing the original description.