Skip to content
cccskills
FreePublished on GitHub

critique-visual-hierarchy

Review a rendered screen to check what attracts attention first, how the eye moves, and which elements stand out. Get specific fixes and severity ratings for problems that hide important information or actions.

OriginalShow the original description

Critique a rendered screen's hierarchy — entry point, eye flow, weight distribution, and emphasis. Use when attention lands in the wrong place. For establishing hierarchy in new work, use `visual-hierarchy` (ui-design).

Run score Not tested

See how to install

Good for

  • Finding why a primary action gets overlooked
  • Reviewing the reading order of a screen
  • Resolving competing areas of emphasis
  • Checking whether decoration distracts from key content

Files included (1)

  • SKILL.md2.4 KB

SKILL.md (original)

Review the instructions the agent will receive before you install.

Critique Visual Hierarchy

You are an expert in visual hierarchy and screen-level design critique.

What You Do

You analyse a screen to identify whether hierarchy is clear, intentional, and aligned with user goals. You flag problems and suggest targeted fixes.

Critique Dimensions

Entry Point

The first element that captures the eye. Evaluate whether it is the most important thing on screen.

  • Is there a single dominant element, or does attention scatter?
  • Does size, contrast, or position establish the entry point clearly?
  • Does the entry point match the primary user goal for this screen?

Eye Flow

The path a user's eye travels after landing. Evaluate whether the path is deliberate and efficient.

  • Does the layout follow an F-pattern, Z-pattern, or intentional reading order?
  • Are there dead ends, loops, or confusing jumps?
  • Does flow lead naturally to the primary call-to-action?

Weight

The relative visual importance of each element. Evaluate whether weight is distributed purposefully.

  • Are size differentials at least 1.5× between hierarchy levels?
  • Is bold/heavy type used sparingly so it retains signal value?
  • Do background fill, stroke weight, and iconography add or fight the hierarchy?

Emphasis

Specific elements that demand extra attention. Evaluate whether emphasis is earned and singular.

  • Is there exactly one primary emphasis zone per view?
  • Are colour, contrast, or motion used to emphasise — or overused so they cancel out?
  • Does the highest-emphasis element match stakeholder and user priority?

Output Format

For each dimension — Entry Point, Eye Flow, Weight, Emphasis — provide:

  1. Observation — what you see (neutral, factual)
  2. Problem — what is broken and why it matters
  3. Fix — a specific, actionable change Rate each dimension: pass / minor issue / major issue.

Common Failure Patterns

  • Multiple competing primaries — nothing reads as most important
  • Hierarchy flattening — too similar in size, weight, or colour across levels
  • False emphasis — decorative elements outweigh functional ones
  • Buried CTA — the action is visually quieter than surrounding content

Reviews

No reviews yet. Tell others what you thought.

Comments

No login needed. Share how it worked for you, ask a question, or note where it did not run.

No comments yet. Be the first to write one.

Comments are published right away. Do not include personal information such as email addresses or phone numbers. Up to 2 URLs.

0 / 1,000 characters

This form is protected by reCAPTCHA, and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

More skills from this repository

a-b-test-design

FreeSummary

Plan A/B experiments to measure the effect of a design change. Define a hypothesis, control and treatment versions, success metrics, sample size, and duration, with supporting measures to detect unintended consequences.

  • Planning a comparison between current and proposed designs
  • Defining success metrics for a change
  • Estimating sample size and test duration
Owl-Listener/designer-skills3.1KUpdated Sep 6, 2026

Assess an existing interface against WCAG 2.2 accessibility guidelines. Identify barriers in content and interactions, rate their severity and user impact, and document affected locations, remediation steps, and code examples to guide improvements.

  • Reviewing accessibility in an existing design or build
  • Checking keyboard access and assistive technology compatibility
  • Prioritizing fixes by severity and user impact
Owl-Listener/designer-skills3.1KUpdated Sep 6, 2026

Plan accessibility testing with people who use assistive technologies, such as screen readers and voice control. Define participant criteria, test environments, session procedures, coverage of WCAG accessibility guidelines, and a consistent format for reporting issues.

  • Planning test sessions with assistive technology users
  • Defining participant recruitment criteria
  • Mapping key user flows to test environments
Owl-Listener/designer-skills3.1KUpdated Sep 6, 2026

Review visual consistency to understand how an interface shapes trust and perceived ease of use. Examine spacing, alignment, typography, and overlooked screen states to guide visual improvements alongside usability testing.

  • Investigating poor feedback on a functional interface
  • Checking visual consistency before launch
  • Reviewing error, empty, and loading states
Owl-Listener/designer-skills3.1KUpdated Sep 6, 2026

affinity-diagram

FreeSummary

Turn interview notes, observations, and survey responses into themes and actionable research insights. Group related evidence without preset categories, retain participant references, and prioritize findings by their impact on design decisions while noting patterns found in only one interview.

  • Synthesize findings across multiple interviews
  • Organize observation notes and survey responses
  • Prioritize research insights for design decisions
Owl-Listener/designer-skills3.1KUpdated Sep 6, 2026

Refine a specific interface animation by choosing easing, meaning changes in speed, along with duration and movement order. Use it to tune buttons, modals, transitions, or loading indicators so motion guides attention and communicates changes.

  • Tune how a modal enters and exits
  • Adjust button and toggle animations
  • Coordinate the order of related movements
Owl-Listener/designer-skills3.1KUpdated Sep 6, 2026

See all skills by Owl-Listener

Report a problem with this skill